Palace took a 19th-minute lead when Neil Danns swept the ball home from six yards. A crowd of just 8,690 saw Wednesday level through Clint Hills' own goal but Andrew took advantage of hesitant defending to fire a left-footed winner.
But what happened to that Wednesday team? Scroll down to find out.
1. Lee Grant
Currently a back-up goalkeeper to David De Gea at Manchester United but hasn’t made a Premier League appearance yet. Photo: Mark Thompson
2. Tommy Spurr
He was released by Preston at the end of the 2018/19 season. Spurr announced his retirement from professional football due to injury last June. Photo: Clive Brunskill
3. Darren Purse
Now Oxford United’s academy coach and director of football at Malcolm Arnold Academy. Photo: Pete Norton
4. Mark Beevers
Currently playing for Darren Ferguson promotion-chasers Peterborough United in League One. Photo: Clive Brunskill